Internet brand Violet Voss will soon release the "Ride or Die" palette, which has an entirely over the top and unnecessary 42 shadows.
And I won't be buying.
As a disclaimer, I am angry today. And I suspect I will be angry for a long time. I didn't put up a post yesterday because it was a horrendous day for me. This is a blog about makeup, not politics, and I'm certainly not inviting any discussion on the topic. But I am in a foul mood as a result of Tuesday's election. So you will have to forgive if some of that anger seeps out into this post about this ridiculous eyeshadow palette that no one needs or wants or voted for... err... never mind.
Violet Voss as a brand is overpriced. I have seen enough reviews of the shadows to know they are of Morphe quality (which is "meh" at best) with double the price tag. They choose trendy colors and use YouTube lingo in their names to appeal to people enamored with the YouTube beauty community. And they use hype tactics to drum up interest in their palettes before giving useful details such as pricing and release date information.
First, this image surfaced:
And I find this really, really obnoxious. Wow! So helpful! Thanks so much for a picture of your EMPTY new palette. So excited!
NO.
This tells me that you are making a new palette. Great. Good for you. So is every other brand. I don't need to see an empty palette to know something is in the works. This is simply a tactic to get people excited, even when they have literally no idea what they are getting excited for.
Then this image surfaced:
Ooo! Extra helpful! A picture of the packaging! Thanks so much for telling me what the outside of the palette will look like! Getting so, so excited!!
Again. No.
This tells me your product has packaging. Awesome.
And then these:
I truthfully have no idea if these images were released one at a time or all at once, but it seems pretty deliberate to not provide a picture of the full palette.
Nonetheless, this is what the palette looks like minus the cranberry shades shown above:
And you know what I see? About, what? 15 or so distinct colors. And those colors repeated several times over until you get 42 shadows.
Some colors (like the silver-gray on the far left, the matte browns on the bottom of column 3, and the entire row of golds) look like the exact color has just been put in a couple or more times.
These are not 42 distinct colors! And because of that, you really don't need this palette.
At the time that I am writing this post, there is no price listed for this palette or a release date. Violet Voss has just said—which is so helpful—"coming soon." But based on the price of the "Holy Grail" palette, which retails for $45 with $6+ shipping for 20 shadows, "Ride or Die" is likely pretty expensive.
But you won't be paying for a unique palette, a high quality palette, or a diverse palette. Hell, you're not even paying for a palette with completely different shades. This is the McDonalds Supersize fries of eyeshadow palettes. And you definitely don't need it.
Here are some similar palettes:
The Morphe 35O is the closest in color selection, shade range, and number of eyeshadows. And it's also similar in quality. Except the Morphe palette is $23.
This also looks like the Naked palette:
And the Lorac Pro:
And the Chocolate Bar:
And the Semi-Sweet Chocolate Bar:
And the Lime Crime Venus:
And the Modern Renaissance:
Even their own Holy Grail:
Chances are, no matter what eyeshadow palette or collection of singles that you have in your makeup collection, you have something that already replicates this palette. And if not, if you are a total beginner and are excited by the possibility of having a lot of shadows to play with, the "Ride or Die" is still a bad purchase. It will be expensive for shadows that repeat themselves. You would be much better off buying any of the palettes listed above or purchasing a few select singles from MAC or Makeup Geek.
I may be in the minority here, but I find the name of this palette obnoxious. It is my understanding that the term "Ride or Die" gained popularity in the YouTube beauty community specifically (not outside of it) because it was a phrase mega popular YouTube personality Jaclyn Hill used frequently. Jaclyn Hill also created the immensely popular "Ride or Die Tag," where people discussed their absolute favorite products from each makeup category.
Few YouTube personalities using this term while applying makeup understand that it became popularized in hip hop and predominately black culture. The term was originally "ride or die chick," referring to a woman who "stands by her man" in the vein of Bonnie and Clyde. I find it—complicated—that white people are appropriating black culture and African American Vernacular English so heavily in the YouTube makeup community.
It annoyed me when Violet Voss named their other successful palette the "Holy Grail" palette as well. The terms "Holy Grail" and "Ride or Die" to most people who watch YouTube makeup videos mean "absolute best" or "most favorite." Calling your palettes these names tells me that you think your palette will be the "absolute best" palette in my collection. I find that cocky and a little ridiculous since the quality is "meh" at best.
Violet Voss preys off customers susceptible to hype by providing "sneak peaks" of their products that don't actually contain any information. The tactic is to get people so excited, so afraid that they will miss out if they don't buy a product immediately, that they already make up their minds on buying it before they even see the product. And more importantly, they decide they are going to buy it before they even know the price. And I don't want any part of that. The "Ride or Die" palette is excessive and promises so much and offers nothing. It's the Donald Trump of eyeshadow palettes. And I won't be buying.
Thank you for this post. It feels good to be angry and sad - sangry? angrad? - right now and know I'm not alone. Plus I enjoy your take on make-up. I've been quietly reading for several weeks and appreciate the thoughtfulness of your process. <3 and hugs. - Jaime
ReplyDeleteHi Jaime, thanks for the comment. It made me feel a lot better. I think it really helps right now to not feel alone, so I thank you for that as well. Thank you so much for reading.
DeleteLove your blog!!! A friend of mine just showed it to me and I'm just obsessed!
ReplyDeleteI have a blog myself and I did an anti haul a few months ago, with among others products, guess what? Violet Voss eyeshadow palettes! :D
I totally agree with all you're writing about these brands and their very annoying communication strategies.
I'm so glad I found your blog, it's so cool to see that people are starting to realize and we need more blogs like yours! :)
What an interesting and honest article! I have a blog myself and review products which work for me personally, and not sheepishly follow the beauty community in buying the latest 'must have' item.
ReplyDeleteKeep up the good work!
I bought the palette and swatched all the colors. Surprisingly they look very very different from how they look in the palette!
ReplyDeleteTotally understand where you're coming from on both issues. Sadly, our current state of affairs is troubling at the very least, and it's safe to say that many of us will be feeling sad/angry for a while.
ReplyDeleteAnd I love your totally honest review of this palette and the brand as a whole. And I realize that these tactics are true because Colourpop (who has lots of my money now) uses the exact same tactics of hype, "previews" containing little to no information, and emails/social media posts that scream "It's coming! Better not miss it or it will be gone forever!!". And to someone who has an issue with impulse buying, it's a sure way to make people part with their money on either a lackluster product or an item that isn't giving as much as you hoped.
Thanks again for a great review and reminded that we shouldn't always believe the hype and jump on the wagon for throwing money at new and shiny!
This is brilliant because it's honest! I couldn't agree more. Shared on fb.. Cheers for being genuine.. x
ReplyDeleteThis palette actually infuriated me! A palette with this many pans has so much potential and you could've had every colour you ever needed in there. But no, so many colours are IDENTICAL. it's so bizarre to me. Violet Voss on the whole just annoys me, the gimmicky YouTube names, meh quality, over priced.
ReplyDeleteSorry for all the anger there, haha. Really enjoying your blog.
You're spot on! What a waste of time and money this palette is.
DeleteThank you for this post - I was torn on getting it but I needed to read this, you are completely right a lot of these colors are the same, and I likely have most of these colors already. I really appreciate your brutal honesty, a lot of people are usually "offended" by this. I probably need to read something like this for the Too Faced Natural Love Palette as well XD
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for reading! I actually have a post on the Too Faced Natural Love palette. It was a recent one this month!
DeleteYou know, and I'm so so glad I found this blog, I belong to a few social media groups where they yak about makeup and everyone's hot topic is this palette. "Oh the next palette I'm saving up for". Cosmetics shouldn't have to be like putting away for a car. This annoys the living he'll out of me with this brand and a few others. I recently purchased tarte new eye love you palette and it was $22. A far cry from $68 but when it came it seriously left little to be desired. All the colors are exactly the same. Mud brown. And its an inch thick. They justified this by throwing in a trial size mascara . I can't understand how all these young woman are being pulled into this crazy product craze. But I read what u said about the slang and now it's hip hop and slang culture and makeup isn't just being bought by little white girls anymore, hence the fake eyelashes and all skin colors are wearing extension in their hair. Companies are doing whatever it takes to broaden their base target market and at a ridiculous amount because they know someone is going to pay. Generation hashtag... seriously
ReplyDeleteI agree with most of what you say. Tarte make up is worth every penny though. You just need to work out the needs of the palettes. I have the Tarte Bloom in Clay Matte palette and it's beautiful.I have been tempted more than a few times to buy the Tartelette 2 palette.. Supposedly 12 'new colours', I have most of them in other palettes so manage to allow common sense to intervene before I 'add to cart'. Make up becomes an addiction and an expensive one at that. I did order a limited edition Tarte Eye and Cheek palette last week but the eye colours are in pink and pastel hues which I don't have. Ah yes... I'm a MUA... But, managing (most times) to control it.. Am now focusing on skin care products...
ReplyDeleteCompletely agree. The colours that appeal to me are already in other palettes as you've mentioned. The silvers look something people used to wear in the 1970-80s. The golds have limited use. Great blog post. Very well informed and informative,
ReplyDeleteHello,
ReplyDeleteI'am reading you from France and this blog means a lot for me. You used some great words to describe my mood to. I hope that you stand now better and better. I would just like to bring you a bit of love. Happy New Year and hope you still well.
Kisses from France,
Julie
Hi Julie,
DeleteThank you so much for such an incredibly kind comment. It means a lot to me, and it has really made my day. Thank you, and thank you for reading.
Happy New Year to you as well.